Auxiliary lists: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
Petersuber (talk | contribs) |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
* a database, such as a [http://www.mysql.com/products/enterprise/server.html MySQL] database or a section within [http://www.freebase.com/ Freebase] or [http://fluidinfo.com/ FluidDB]. | * a database, such as a [http://www.mysql.com/products/enterprise/server.html MySQL] database or a section within [http://www.freebase.com/ Freebase] or [http://fluidinfo.com/ FluidDB]. | ||
* a [http://listiki.com/ Listiki] list, which supports crowd-based ranking | * a [http://listiki.com/ Listiki] list, which supports crowd-based ranking | ||
* a spreadsheet, preferably one editable by users such as a [http://www.google.com/google-d-s/spreadsheets/ Google Docs Spreadsheet] | * a spreadsheet, preferably one editable by users such as a [http://www.google.com/google-d-s/spreadsheets/ Google Docs Spreadsheet] | ||
* a table, such as a [http://www.factual.com/ Factual.com] table or [http://tables.googlelabs.com/public/tour/tour1.html Google Fusion] table | * a table, such as a [http://www.factual.com/ Factual.com] table or [http://tables.googlelabs.com/public/tour/tour1.html Google Fusion] table | ||
| Line 22: | Line 21: | ||
As far as possible given the constraints of the alternate format, auxiliary lists should: | As far as possible given the constraints of the alternate format, auxiliary lists should: | ||
# conform to the OAD [[Editorial Policy | editorial policy]] | # conform to the OAD [[Editorial Policy | editorial policy]] | ||
# support user contributions or edits | # support user contributions or edits | ||
# support data export, preferably in some standard format | # support data export, preferably in some standard format | ||
# carry an OAD-editor-approved scope note, the OAD logo, and a link back to the mother ship. | # carry an OAD-editor-approved scope note, the OAD logo, and a link back to the mother ship. | ||
# carry a CC-BY license | |||
<!-- # support a spam-reduction method other than deletion by vigilant users, such as contributor registration --> | <!-- # support a spam-reduction method other than deletion by vigilant users, such as contributor registration --> | ||
<!-- # support a method to restore previous versions after off-topic, incompetent, or malicious edits --> | <!-- # support a method to restore previous versions after off-topic, incompetent, or malicious edits --> | ||
Latest revision as of 09:57, 29 May 2015
This list is part of the Open Access Directory.
OAD auxiliary lists are approved by the OAD editors but not presented in wiki format and therefore not hosted here at the OAD wiki. The argument for auxiliary lists is that not all lists are suited to the wiki format, and many other formats offer advantages that wikis cannot match.
We're considering the addition of auxiliary lists and haven't yet made a decision. We welcome your feedback.
If we go ahead with auxiliary lists, of course we'd create an OAD-based list of our auxiliary lists. That would help users find them, and help users identify which lists hosted elsewhere, perhaps claiming to be part of OAD, are actually part of OAD.
Formats
Here are some of the non-wiki formats we're considering for auxiliary OAD lists.
- a Bibliographica bibliography
- a database, such as a MySQL database or a section within Freebase or FluidDB.
- a Listiki list, which supports crowd-based ranking
- a spreadsheet, preferably one editable by users such as a Google Docs Spreadsheet
- a table, such as a Factual.com table or Google Fusion table
If we adopt auxiliary lists, we'd welcome suggestions for other promising formats.
Criteria
As far as possible given the constraints of the alternate format, auxiliary lists should:
- conform to the OAD editorial policy
- support user contributions or edits
- support data export, preferably in some standard format
- carry an OAD-editor-approved scope note, the OAD logo, and a link back to the mother ship.
- carry a CC-BY license
If a given list or format cannot meet enough of these criteria, the editors will not approve it for inclusion in the OAD.
The OAD editors will review approved auxiliary lists at least once a year to see whether they continue to meet the criteria for approval.