Journal declarations of independence
From Open Access Directory
Revision as of 22:58, 4 November 2015 by Kshawkin (added section for 2015 and reference to Lingua)
This list is part of the Open Access Directory.
- By a journal declaration of independence, we mean the resignation of editors from a journal in order to launch a comparable journal with a friendlier publisher or less-restrictive access policies. The kinds we are collecting for this list usually have two stages. First, an editor or group of editors resigns from a journal in order to protest its high subscription price or audience-limiting access rules. This is usually accompanied by a public statement explaining "the causes which impel them to the separation" (to quote Thomas Jefferson). Second, some of the resigning editors create a new free or affordable alternative journal to compete with the first and to embody their vision of wide access.
- We include a few cases in which editors resigned en masse from a journal to protest restrictive access policies, but have not (or not yet) launched a new, less-restrictive journal.
- We borrow the term "declaration of independence" for this phenomenon from the SPARC project to assist journals in Declaring Independence. Of course, SPARC borrowed the term from the U.S. Declaration of Independence.
- Chronological order.
- In June 1989, Editor Eddy van der Maarel and most of his editorial board resigned from Vegetatio (W. Junk, then Nijhoff, then Kluwer) in order to launch the Journal of Vegetation Science (Opulus Press and the International Association for Vegetation Science).
- (old journal, new name) Plant Ecology
- (new journal) Journal of Vegetation Science (inactive link; now published here)
- Robert Peet's brief account of the background.
- Van der Maarel's statement on the background of his resignation. November 8, 1998.
- Van der Maarel's editorial for the first issue Journal of Vegetation Science (February 1990) on the need for the new journal.
- JVS became a SPARC partner in March 2002.
- In December 1996, Shu-Kun Lin resigned as editor of Molecules, then published by Springer-Verlag, and relaunched the journal with Molecular Diversity Preservation International (MDPI). Springer sued to prevent Shu-Kun Lin from using the same for the MDPI journal but eventually dropped its suit.
- In November 1998, Michael Rosenzweig and the rest of his editorial board resigned from Evolutionary Ecology (Chapman & Hall, then International Thomson, now Kluwer), which Rosenzweig had launched in 1986, in order to create Evolutionary Ecology Research. Its birth and early survival were assisted by SPARC.
- In 1998 most of the editorial board of the Journal of Academic Librarianship resigned to protest the large hike in the subscription price imposed by Pergamon-Elsevier after it bought the journal from JAI Press. Several of the editors who resigned then created Portal: Libraries and the Academy at Johns Hopkins University Press.
- (old journal) Journal of Academic Librarianship.
- (new journal) Portal: Libraries and the Academy.
- Gloriana St. Clair's statement in Portal 1.1 on the need for Portal. Accessible only to paid MUSE subscribers.
- Steve McKinzie and Jocelyn Godolphin's comments on the resignations
- Tony Seward's reply and correction to McKenzie's comments.
- Coverage in FOSN for 10/26/01.
- In November 1999, the entire 50 person editorial board of the Journal of Logic Programming (Elsevier) resigned and formed a new journal, Theory and Practice of Logic Programming (Cambridge). Its birth and early survival were assisted by SPARC.
- In January 2000 (to take effect in July 2000), Henry Hagedorn resigned as editor of the Archives of Insect Biochemistry & Physiology (Wiley-Liss) in order to form the Journal of Insect Science (originally, University of Arizona Library, now University of Wisconsin Library). JIS is a free online journal with no print edition. It is now supported entirely by the University of Wisconsin Memorial Library and charges no author-side fees. Its birth and early survival were assisted by SPARC.
- Early in 2001, a handful of editors of Topology and Its Applications (Elsevier) resigned in order to create Algebraic and Geometric Topology (University of Warwick and International Press), a free online journal with an annual printed volume. Its birth and early survival were assisted by SPARC.
- (old journal) Topology and Its Applications
- (new journal) Algebraic and Geometric Topology
- Joan Birman's statement on some of the background of the resignations; see also her 2000 article in Notices of the AMS.
- Haynes Miller's public letter of resignation.
- SPARC's press release on the launch of Algebraic and Geometric Topology.
- Over a nine month period in 2001, forty editors of Machine Learning (Kluwer) resigned from the editorial board and published their reasons in a public letter dated October 8, 2001. One of those resigning, Leslie Pack Kaelbling, created the Journal of Machine Learning Research as a free online alternative with a quarterly print edition published by MIT Press. About two-thirds of the Machine Learning editors joined her at the new journal.
- Elsevier has published the European Economic Review since 1969. In 1986 the European Economic Association (EEA) adopted it as its official journal. But the EEA grew increasingly unhappy with Elsevier's subscription price and its requirement that the publisher, not the association, hire the journal's editors. In 2001 the EEA started the process of declaring independence from Elsevier. In March 2003 its new official journal, the Journal of the European Economic Association, was launched by MIT Press at about one-third of the Elsevier subscription price.
- (old journal) European Economic Review
- (new journal) Journal of the European Economic Association
- European Economic Association
- The JEEA's page on its history and decision to break with Elsevier.
- Coverage in the March 21, 2003 issue of the Chronicle of Higher Education (story accessible only to CHE subscribers).
- On July 3, 2003, The entire 40+ person editorial board Labor History (Taylor and Francis) resigned in protest over the journal's high subscription price and lack of editorial independence. The same editors then launched Labor with non-profit Duke University Press. Labor is a partner of SPARC, which assisted in the transition and launch.
- (old journal) Labor History
- (new journal) Labor: Studies in Working Class History in the Americas
- SPARC press release
- On August 13, 2003, the Society for the Internet in Medicine named the open-access Journal of Medical Internet Research as its new official journal, replacing the subscription-based Medical Informatics & Internet in Medicine. (This is a decision by a scholarly society, not journal editors, but I include it on the list because of the family resemblance to a true declaration of independence.)
- On September 22, 2003, Compositio Mathematica announced that it was leaving Kluwer to be published by the London Mathematical Society and distributed by Cambridge University Press (starting in January 2004). The journal's editor of 20+ years, Gerard van der Geer, explained in a public note that the move was triggered by a long series of unwanted Kluwer price increases. The LMS edition of the journal is not free, but priced one-third below the former price.
- On December 31, 2003, the entire editorial board of the Journal of Algorithms resigned in order to protest the high price charged by the publisher (Elsevier). On January 21, 2004, the same board then launched a new journal, Transactions on Algorithms, published by the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM).
- (old journal) Journal of Algorithms (Elsevier)
- (new journal) Transactions on Algorithms (ACM)
- Letter from Donald E. Knuth to fellow members of the Journal Algorithms editorial board outlining the problem, describing the open-access solution, and asking them to choose among four options.
- Public statement by the former Journal of Algorithms editors explaining their resignation. Slated to appear in the March 2004 issue of SIGACT News.
- Hal Gabow has the dates and some other details on his home page.
- George Porter discusses some of the aftermath in a May 14, 2004 STLQ blog posting.
- On January 27, 2004, Editor in Chief Dominique Boullier and the entire editorial board of Les cahiers du numérique resigned from the journal and released an open letter explaining why. They point to CduN's high price and limited online access policy which "contradict our objectives as researchers".
- In 2005, Editors Charles and Marie-Louise Steele, George Herrmann, and "21 of the 23 members of the IJSS board of editors" resigned from the International Journal of Solids and Structures (IJSS) because "there was no indication that the commercial publishers were reversing the pressure for increased profits out of the limited institutional resources"; details on the "Background of JoMMS" may be found in a comment from Charles Steele to a June 2006 iMechanica article.
- On February 20, 2006, the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) dismissed the journal's editor-in-chief John Hoey and editor Anne Marie Todkill. In response, there was "a mass exodus of journal staff, including most of the editorial board." See details provided here.
- (old journal) Canadian Medical Association Journal
- (new journal) Open Medicine
- Editorial on need for autonomy on the part of CMAJ's editorial board, following the loss of Hoey and Todkill.
- Letter from CMAJ's remaining editors regarding the dismissal.
- Article about the launch of Open Medicine.
- Coverage in OAN for July 15, 2006.
- On August 10, 2006, the editorial board of Topology resigned (effective December 31, 2006) over concerns about the high price charged by the journal's publisher (Elsevier).
- (old journal) Topology
- (new journal) Journal of Topology
- Letter from the editorial board announcing the resignations.
- Announcement about the launch of the new journal (includes a statement on pricing policy).
- Find news about the resignation in the following: August 10, 2006 blog post by Peter Woit, October 26, 2006 article in the New York Sun, October 27, 2006 ACRLog post, November 10, 2006 article in the Chronicle of Higher Education (accessible only to subscribers), January 25, 2007 article in Nature (accessible only to subscribers), and May 2007 issue of the Notices of the AMS.
- Coverage in OAN for October 26, 2006. Further details noted in OAN for October 27, 2006.
- In June 2007, the Association for Symbolic Logic (ASL), having been dissatisfied with "unsatisfactory relations" with Springer, launched a "successor" journal to the Journal of Philosophical Logic with Cambridge University Press; details on the Review of Symbolic Logic are discussed the ASL president Penelope Maddy's letter to the association's members below.
- In August 2007, the editorial board of K-Theory resigned, citing Springer's exorbitant pricing structures and slow production times as the reasons for doing so. Unlike other similar declarations by editorial boards, this split was particularly contentious. Anthony Bak, one of the editors who resigned, withheld articles for publication in K-Theory for over a year, which he then offered publication in the newly created Journal of K-Theory (see linked texts below for additional information).
- (old journal) K-Theory
- (new journal) Journal of K-Theory
- Editorial Board's statement on the reason for resignation, posted on Peter Woit's blog.
- Chronicle of Higher Education article on the controversy surrounding the establishment of the Journal of K-Theory.
- K-Theory's Wolfgang Lueck and Andrew Ranicki released a statement following Anthony Bak's resignation and the ensuing conflict over missing papers, and Anthony Bak responded to these concerns, which is detailed in Peter Woit's blog.
- Coverage in OAN from August 10, 2007. Coverage in Not Even Wrong for August 17, 2007. Coverage in Nature from August 23, 2007.
- In 2008, Annales Scientifiques de l'École Normale Supérieure stopped publishing with Elsevier and moved to Société Mathématique de France as a publisher. There is no declaration of independence available.
- (old journal) Annales Scientifiques de l'École Normale Supérieure
- (new journal) Annales Scientifiques de l'École Normale Supérieure
- Find a brief note on the Annales Scientifiques de l'École Normale Supérieure's change in publisher in Peter Woit's blog.
- Coverage in OAN from August 10, 2007.
- On October 18, 2012 (effective December 1, 2012), 25 members of the editorial board resigned from the journal, Organization & Environment.
- (old journal) Organization & Environment (from Sage Publications)
- See the editors' statement of the reasons for their resignation, Sage's response to the editors' statement (quoted in a news story in Inside Higher Ed), and the editors' response to Sage's response.
- Coverage in Inside Higher Ed and Monthly Review.
- On March 23, 2013, the entire editorial board of the Journal of Library Administration resigned.
- In late October 2015, the entire editorial board of Lingua resigned.
- Coverage in Inside Higher Ed.